TagLine Here

All Products




... more info
 Sold Out 
10 year Extra Sharp Cheddar
Price: $17.99

Weight: 13oz

Add:
11 year Extra Sharp Cheddar
Price: $18.99

Weight: 13oz

Add:
12 year Extra Sharp Cheddar
Price: $19.99

Weight: 13oz

Add:
3 year Extra Sharp Cheddar
Price: $10.99

Weight: 13oz

Add:
34 Degrees Natural Crisps
Price: $4.29

Weight: 4.5oz

Add:
4 year Extra Sharp Cheddar
Price: $11.99

Weight: 13oz

Add:
40 oz. Old Wisconsin Beef Snack Bites
Price: $20.99

Weight: 40oz

Add:
5 year Extra Sharp Cheddar
Price: $12.99

Weight: 13oz

Add:
8 year Extra Sharp Cheddar
Price: $15.99

Weight: 13oz

Add:
Aged Asiago Cheese Spread - Large
Price: $5.49

Weight: 15oz

Add:
Aged Asiago Cheese Spread - Small
Price: $3.79

Weight: 7oz

Add:
Aged Brick
Price: $7.79

Weight: 15oz

Add:
Aged Cheddar
Price: $5.99

Weight: 13oz

Add:
Apple Cider Jam
Price: $7.95

Weight: 11.75oz

Add:
Asiago
Price: $6.99

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Baby Swiss
Price: $7.19

Weight: 12oz

Add:
Bacon Cheddar
Price: $5.99

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Bacon Juusto
Price: $5.79

Weight: 7oz

Add:
Balsamic Bellavitano
Price: $6.99

Weight: 5.3oz

... more info
 Sold Out 
Bertram's - Black Raspberry Jam
Price: $7.49

Weight: 9oz

Add:
Bertram's - Cherry Almond Syrup
Price: $7.99

Weight: 12oz

Add:
Bertram's - Christmas Jam
Price: $7.49

Weight: 9oz

Add:
Bertram's - Mom's Pepper Jelly
Price: $7.49

Weight: 9oz

Add:
Black Pepper Bellavitano
Price: $6.99

Weight: 5.3oz

Add:
Blazing Buffalo Cheddar
Price: $5.99

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Blue Cheese
Price: $5.99

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Blueberry Cobbler Heritage Cheddar
Price: $5.49

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Bourbon Pecan Caramel Sauce
Price: $7.95

Weight: 12.5oz

Add:
Cajun Cheese Curds
Price: $4.89

Weight: 10oz

Add:
Caramelized Onion Mustard
Price: $6.50

Weight: 7.75oz

Add:
Caraway Cheddar
Price: $5.49

Weight: 13oz

Add:
Caraway Muenster
Price: $6.49

Weight: 12oz

Add:
Cheese Can Cozie
Price: $8.00

Weight: 0oz

Add:
Cheese Curd Batter Mix
Price: $3.99

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Cheese Slicer
Price: $3.99

Weight: 0oz

Add:
Cheesehead - Large
Price: $16.79

Weight: 0oz

Add:
Cheesehead - Small
Price: $11.50

Weight: 0oz

Add:
Chipotle Cheddar
Price: $5.49

Weight: 13oz

Add:
Chipotle Juusto
Price: $5.79

Weight: 7oz

Add:
Chunky Bleu Flavor Cheese Spread - Large
Price: $5.49

Weight: 15oz

Add:
Chunky Bleu Flavor Cheese Spread - Small
Price: $3.49

Weight: 7oz

Add:
Cinnamon Apple Pie Heritage Cheddar
Price: $4.89

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Classic Pizza Sauce
Price: $3.95

Weight: 8.25oz

Add:
Colby
Price: $4.99

Weight: 13oz

Add:
Colby Jack
Price: $5.49

Weight: 13oz

Add:
Colored Cheese Curds
Price: $4.89

Weight: 10oz

Add:
Cow Pie
Price: $3.59

Weight: 2.5oz

Add:
Cow Pie - Dark Chocolate
Price: $3.59

Weight: 2.5oz

Add:
Cow Pie - Peanut Butter
Price: $3.59

Weight: 2.8oz

Add:
Cowtown Cookies
Price: $2.25

Weight: 2oz

Add:
Cranberry Muenster
Price: $6.49

Weight: 7.5oz

Add:
Creamy Caramel Heritage Cheddar
Price: $4.69

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Crumbled Blue Cheese
Price: $5.49

Weight: 4oz

Add:
Dairy Fudge With Walnuts
Price: $6.99

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Dill Havarti
Price: $5.99

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Dipping Pretzels
Price: $2.99

Weight: 6oz

Add:
Door County - Blackberry
Price: $12.99

Weight: 0oz

Add:
Door County - Cranberry
Price: $12.99

Weight: 0oz

Add:
Door County - Mad About Mango
Price: $12.99

Weight: 0oz

Add:
Door County - Razzle Dazzle Raspberry
Price: $12.99

Weight: 0oz

Add:
Door County - Strawberry
Price: $12.99

Weight: 0oz

Add:
Door County - Strawberry Zin
Price: $12.99

Weight: 0oz

Add:
Door County - Sweet Cherry
Price: $12.99

Weight: 0oz

Add:
Door County Coffee – Almond Toffee
Price: $2.49

Weight: 1.5oz

Add:
Door County Coffee – Amaretto
Price: $2.49

Weight: 1.5oz

Add:
Door County Coffee – Caramel Pecan Scones
Price: $2.49

Weight: 1.5oz

Add:
Door County Coffee – Chocolate Raspberry Truffle
Price: $2.49

Weight: 1.5oz

Add:
Door County Coffee – Dublin's Delight
Price: $2.49

Weight: 1.5oz

Add:
Door County Coffee – Heavenly Caramel
Price: $2.49

Weight: 1.5oz

Add:
Door County Coffee – Highlander Grogg
Price: $2.49

Weight: 1.5oz

Add:
Door County Coffee – Irish Cream
Price: $2.49

Weight: 1.5oz

Add:
Door County Coffee – Vanilla Cappuccino
Price: $1.99

Weight: 1.5oz

Add:
Door Peninsula Winery - Plum Loco
Price: $12.99

Weight: 0oz

... more info
 Sold Out 
Door Peninsula Winery - Sunset Splash
Price: $12.99

Weight: 0oz

Add:
Dragon's Breath Cheddar
Price: $5.99

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Edam
Price: $5.49

Weight: 7oz

Add:
Espresso Bellavitano
Price: $6.99

Weight: 5.3oz

Add:
Farmers
Price: $5.49

Weight: 13oz

Add:
Farmers Dill
Price: $5.99

Weight: 13oz

Add:
Farmers Pepper
Price: $5.99

Weight: 13oz

Add:
Fisherman's Choice Breading & Batter Mix
Price: $3.39

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Fontina
Price: $6.99

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Garden Vegetable Cheese Spread - Large
Price: $5.49

Weight: 15oz

Add:
Garden Vegetable Cheese Spread - Small
Price: $3.79

Weight: 7oz

Add:
Garlic & Dill Cheddar
Price: $5.49

Weight: 13oz

Add:
Garlic & Dill Cheese Curds
Price: $4.89

Weight: 10oz

Add:
Garlic & Herb Cheese Spread - Large
Price: $5.49

Weight: 16oz

Add:
Garlic & Herb Cheese Spread - Small
Price: $3.79

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Ghost Pepper Cheese Spread - Small
Price: $3.49

Weight: 7oz

Add:
Gift Box 1
Price: $15.00

Weight: 0oz

Add:
Gift Box 2
Price: $25.00

Weight: 0oz

Add:
Gift Box 3
Price: $30.00

Weight: 0oz

Add:
Gift Box 4
Price: $40.00

Weight: 0oz

Add:
Gift Box 5
Price: $45.00

Weight: 0oz

Add:
Gift Box 6
Price: $55.00

Weight: 0oz

Add:
Goat Cheese - Country Jack
Price: $6.99

Weight: 8oz

... more info
 Sold Out 
Goat Cheese - Country Jack w/Garlic
Price: $6.99

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Goat Cheese - Country Jack w/Tomato & Basil
Price: $6.99

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Goat Cheese - Mild Cheddar
Price: $6.99

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Gold Bellavitano
Price: $6.99

Weight: 5.3oz

Add:
Golden Fenugreek Cheddar
Price: $5.99

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Gouda
Price: $5.49

Weight: 7oz

... more info
 Sold Out 
Green and Gold Cheddar Cheese Spread
Price: $5.49

Weight: 16oz

Add:
Green and Gold Cheddar with Beer Cheese Spread
Price: $5.49

Weight: 16oz

Add:
Habanero Jack
Price: $5.49

Weight: 13oz

Add:
Hatch Pepper Heritage Cheddar
Price: $5.99

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Havarti
Price: $5.99

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Henning's Cheese Knife
Price: $4.49

Weight: 0oz

Add:
Henning’s Cheese 16 oz. Double Walled Plastic Cup
Price: $8.49

Weight: 0oz

Add:
Herb & Spice Havarti
Price: $6.49

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Hickory Smoked String Cheese
Price: $5.29

Weight: 10oz

Add:
Holiday Jam
Price: $5.69

Weight: 12.5oz

Add:
Horseradish & Chive Havarti
Price: $6.49

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Horseradish Cheese Spread - Large
Price: $5.49

Weight: 16oz

Add:
Horseradish Cheese Spread - Small
Price: $3.79

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Horseradish Mustard
Price: $6.50

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Hot Habanero Cheese Spread - Small
Price: $3.49

Weight: 7oz

Add:
Italiano Juusto
Price: $5.79

Weight: 7oz

Add:
Jalapeño Cheese Spread - Large
Price: $5.49

Weight: 16oz

Add:
Jalapeño Cheese Spread - Small
Price: $3.79

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Jalapeño Juusto
Price: $5.79

Weight: 7oz

Add:
Johnsonville Garlic Summer Sausage - Large
Price: $7.99

Weight: 20oz

Add:
Johnsonville Garlic Summer Sausage - Small
Price: $5.99

Weight: 12oz

Add:
Johnsonville Summer Sausage - Large
Price: $7.99

Weight: 20oz

Add:
Johnsonville Summer Sausage - Small
Price: $5.99

Weight: 12oz

Add:
Landjaeger
Price: $4.39

Weight: 4.5oz

Add:
Limburger
Price: $5.99

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Limburger Spread
Price: $5.49

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Mango Fire Heritage Cheddar
Price: $5.49

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Maple Bacon Onion Jam
Price: $7.95

Weight: 11.75oz

Add:
Mediterranean Sunset Heritage Cheddar
Price: $5.99

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Medium Cheddar
Price: $5.49

Weight: 13oz

Add:
Merlot Bellavitano
Price: $6.99

Weight: 5.3oz

Add:
Miesfeld's Garlic Summer Sausage
Price: $5.99

Weight: 12oz

Add:
Miesfeld's Snacking Bologna
Price: $5.99

Weight: 16oz

Add:
Miesfeld's Summer Sausage
Price: $5.99

Weight: 12oz

Add:
Mild Cheddar
Price: $4.99

Weight: 13oz

Add:
Mini Cow Pie
Price: $0.89

Weight: 0.48oz

Add:
Montamore
Price: $6.99

Weight: 7oz

Add:
Monterey Jack
Price: $4.99

Weight: 13oz

Add:
Mozza Whips
Price: $5.29

Weight: 10oz

Add:
Mozzarella
Price: $4.99

Weight: 13oz

Add:
Muenster
Price: $6.49

Weight: 13oz

Add:
Onion & Chives Cheddar
Price: $5.49

Weight: 13oz

Add:
Parmesan
Price: $7.99

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Peach Amaretto Jam
Price: $7.95

Weight: 12.5oz

Add:
Pepper Cheese Curds
Price: $4.89

Weight: 10oz

Add:
Pepper Jack
Price: $5.49

Weight: 13oz

Add:
Pepper Jack Cheese Spread - Large
Price: $5.49

Weight: 16oz

Add:
Pepper Jack Cheese Spread - Small
Price: $3.49

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Pepper Sticks
Price: $4.39

Weight: 4.5oz

Add:
Peppercorn Heritage Cheddar
Price: $6.99

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Pico de Queso Cheddar
Price: $5.99

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Piña Colada Cheddar
Price: $5.99

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Plain Juusto
Price: $5.79

Weight: 7oz

Add:
Port Wine Cheese Spread - Large
Price: $5.49

Weight: 16oz

Add:
Port Wine Cheese Spread - Small
Price: $3.79

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Process Bacon American
Price: $5.99

Weight: 13oz

Add:
Process Salami American
Price: $5.99

Weight: 13oz

Add:
Prodyne Beechwood Cheese Slicer
Price: $15.99

Weight: 0oz

Add:
Provolone
Price: $5.99

Weight: 14oz

Add:
Ranch Cheese Curds
Price: $4.89

Weight: 10oz

Add:
Raspberry Bellavitano
Price: $6.99

Weight: 5.3oz

Add:
Regular Swiss
Price: $7.49

Weight: 11oz

Add:
Roasted Garlic Mustard
Price: $6.50

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Roasted Garlic Onion Jam
Price: $7.95

Weight: 13oz

Add:
Romano
Price: $6.99

Weight: 5oz

Add:
Salsa Asiago
Price: $6.99

Weight: 5.3oz

Add:
Sharp Cheddar
Price: $6.99

Weight: 13oz

Add:
Sharp Cheddar Cheese Spread - Large
Price: $5.49

Weight: 16oz

Add:
Sheboygan County 4-H Cookbook
Price: $19.95

Weight: 0oz

Add:
Sliced Process American - 3 pounds
Price: $12.99

Weight: 48oz

Add:
Sliced Process American - 5 pounds
Price: $18.99

Weight: 80oz

Add:
Smoked Baby Swiss
Price: $7.19

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Smoked Gouda
Price: $5.49

Weight: 7oz

Add:
Smoked Provolone
Price: $5.99

Weight: 14oz

Add:
Smokey Bacon Cheese Spread - Large
Price: $5.49

Weight: 16oz

Add:
Smokey Bacon Cheese Spread - Small
Price: $3.79

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Smokey Sharp Cheddar
Price: $6.19

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Smokey Swiss & Cheddar
Price: $6.19

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Sour Cherry Jam
Price: $7.95

Weight: 12.5oz

Add:
Spicy Beer Cheese Spread - Large
Price: $5.49

Weight: 15oz

Add:
Spicy Beer Cheese Spread - Small
Price: $3.49

Weight: 7oz

Add:
Spicy Honey Mustard
Price: $6.50

Weight: 8oz

Add:
String Cheese
Price: $5.29

Weight: 10oz

... more info
 Sold Out 
Sweet Cherry Heritage Cheddar
Price: $5.59

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Sweet Honey Mustard
Price: $6.50

Weight: 8.5oz

Add:
Swiss & Almond Cheese Spread - Large
Price: $5.49

Weight: 16oz

Add:
Swiss & Almond Cheese Spread - Small
Price: $3.79

Weight: 7oz

... more info
 Sold Out 
Taco Sticks
Price: $4.39

Weight: 4.5oz

Add:
Toasted Onion Cheese Spread - Large
Price: $5.49

Weight: 16oz

Add:
Toasted Onion Cheese Spread - Small
Price: $3.79

Weight: 8oz

Add:
Tomato Basil Cheddar
Price: $5.49

Weight: 13oz

Add:
Two Tone Cheddar
Price: $5.49

Weight: 13oz

Add:
Two Tone Cheese Curds
Price: $4.89

Weight: 10oz

Add:
Von Stiehl - Cherry Kirsche
Price: $16.99

Weight: 0oz

Add:
Von Stiehl - Crimson Royale
Price: $12.99

Weight: 0oz

Add:
Von Stiehl - Naughty Girl
Price: $15.19

Weight: 0oz

Add:
Von Stiehl - Oktoberfest
Price: $14.99

Weight: 0oz

Add:
Von Stiehl - Satin Red
Price: $13.99

Weight: 0oz