TagLine Here

Henning’s Cheddar

All cheese displayed on this page is manufactured by Henning’s Cheese. Henning’s Cheese uses all natural ingredients and is Kosher approved. Henning’s Cheese supports small family dairy farmers who grass feed their cows.



Product Image Item Name Price
10 year Extra Sharp Cheddar

10 year Extra Sharp Cheddar

Colored Cheddar aged over 10 years.
$17.99

Add:

3 year Extra Sharp Cheddar

3 year Extra Sharp Cheddar

White Cheddar aged over 3 years.
$10.99

Add:

4 year Extra Sharp Cheddar

4 year Extra Sharp Cheddar

Colored Cheddar aged over 4 years.
$11.99

Add:

5 year Extra Sharp Cheddar

5 year Extra Sharp Cheddar

Colored Cheddar aged over 5 years.
$12.99

Add:

8 year Extra Sharp Cheddar

8 year Extra Sharp Cheddar

Colored Cheddar aged over 8 years.
$15.99

Add:

Aged Cheddar

Aged Cheddar

Colored cheddar aged over 6 months.
$5.99

Add:

Bacon Cheddar

Bacon Cheddar

Yellow Cheddar blended with real bacon pieces.
$5.99  $5.29
Save: 12% off


Add:

Blazing Buffalo Cheddar

Blazing Buffalo Cheddar

Spicy hot peppers blended in a creamy colored natural Cheddar.
$5.99

Add:

Blueberry Cobbler Heritage Cheddar

Blueberry Cobbler Heritage Cheddar

White Cheddar cheese blended perfectly with blueberries. Suggestions: A great addition to your holiday meal. Slice thinly and add to your bagel or...
$5.49

Add:

Caraway Cheddar

Caraway Cheddar

White Cheddar blended with caraway seeds.
$5.49  $4.79
Save: 13% off


Add:

Chipotle Cheddar

Chipotle Cheddar

White Cheddar blended with roasted jalapeños. Winner of both U.S. and World cheese competition awards. Suggestions: Add to your favorite Mexican dish.
$5.49

Add:

Cinnamon Apple Pie Heritage Cheddar

Cinnamon Apple Pie Heritage Cheddar

White Cheddar cheese blended with perfect amount of apples and cinnamon. It tastes as good as it sounds and makes a great addition to your apple pie.
$4.89

Add:

Creamy Caramel Heritage Cheddar

Creamy Caramel Heritage Cheddar

White Cheddar cheese smoothly blended with caramel. It will melt in your mouth. Suggestions: A great addition to your holiday meal. Cube and serve...
$4.69

Add:

Dragon's Breath Cheddar

Dragon's Breath Cheddar

Fire breathing peppers heats up our cheddar. IF YOU LOVED OUR SCORPION CHEDDAR, THIS IS THE PERFECT CHEESE FOR YOU!
$5.99

Add:

Garlic & Dill Cheddar

Garlic & Dill Cheddar

White Cheddar blended with garlic and dill. Suggestions: Enjoy as a grilled cheese sandwich or burger topper.
$5.49  $4.79
Save: 13% off


Add:

Golden Fenugreek Cheddar

Golden Fenugreek Cheddar

A nutty, maple syrup like, flavor in creamy white Cheddar.
$5.99

Add:



Monthly Specials For May

Bacon Cheddar
Bacon Cheddar
$5.99  $5.29
Save: 12% off
Garlic & Dill Cheddar
Garlic & Dill Cheddar
$5.49  $4.79
Save: 13% off
Caraway Cheddar
Caraway Cheddar
$5.49  $4.79
Save: 13% off