TagLine Here

Featured Products





Blazing Buffalo Cheddar

Add:
Blazing Buffalo Cheddar
Manufacturer: Henning's Cheese

Price: $5.99

Weight: 8oz

Spicy hot peppers blended in a creamy colored natural Cheddar.

Chipotle Cheddar

Add:
Chipotle Cheddar
Manufacturer: Henning's Cheese

Price: $5.49

Weight: 13oz

White Cheddar blended with roasted jalapeños. Winner of both U.S. and World cheese competition awards. Suggestions: Add to your favorite Mexican dish.

Dragon's Breath Cheddar

Add:
Dragon's Breath Cheddar
Manufacturer: Henning's Cheese

Price: $5.99  $5.29
Save: 12% off


Weight: 8oz

Fire breathing peppers heats up our cheddar. IF YOU LOVED OUR SCORPION CHEDDAR, THIS IS THE PERFECT CHEESE FOR YOU!

Farmers Pepper

Add:
Farmers Pepper
Manufacturer: Henning's Cheese

Price: $5.99

Weight: 13oz

A semi soft, reduced fat cheese blended with jalapeño peppers.

Ghost Pepper Cheese Spread - Small

Add:
Ghost Pepper Cheese Spread - Small
Manufacturer: Wisconsin Made

Price: $3.49

Weight: 7oz

Sharp Cheddar with explosive ghost peppers. VERY HOT!!!

Habanero Jack

Add:
Habanero Jack
Manufacturer: Henning's Cheese

Price: $5.49

Weight: 13oz

Monterey Jack cheese blended with habanero peppers. HOT but yummy!

Hatch Pepper Cheese Spread

Add:
Hatch Pepper Cheese Spread
Manufacturer: Henning's Cheese

Price: $3.79  $3.29
Save: 13% off


Weight: 8oz

Cold Pack Cheese Spread Authentic “mild” hatch peppers blended in a creamy sharp Cheddar.

Hatch Pepper Heritage Cheddar

Add:
Hatch Pepper Heritage Cheddar
Manufacturer: Henning's Cheese

Price: $5.99

Weight: 8oz

White Cheddar blended with Hatch chili peppers. Sweet and mild flavor.

Hot Habanero Cheese Spread - Large

Add:
Hot Habanero Cheese Spread - Large
Manufacturer: Wisconsin Made

Price: $4.99

Weight: 15oz

Golden Cheddar cheese with a flavorful kick of HOT Habaneros.

Jalapeño Cheese Spread - Large

Add:
Jalapeño Cheese Spread - Large
Manufacturer: Wisconsin Made

Price: $5.49

Weight: 16oz


Mango Fire Heritage Cheddar

Add:
Mango Fire Heritage Cheddar
Manufacturer: Henning's Cheese

Price: $5.49

Weight: 8oz

White Cheddar cheese mixed with mango and habanero peppers. Start with a smooth sweet flavor which then ignites your tastes buds with a little heat ... more info

Pepper Cheese Curds

Add:
Pepper Cheese Curds
Manufacturer: Henning's Cheese

Price: $4.89

Weight: 10oz

Colored Cheddar cheese curds blended with jalapeño peppers. Suggestions: A great appetizer snack. Melt on a pizza. Make homemade mac and cheese. Cut ... more info

Pepper Jack

Add:
Pepper Jack
Manufacturer: Henning's Cheese

Price: $5.49

Weight: 13oz

Monterey Jack cheese blended with jalapeño peppers. Not quite as hot as the Habanero Jack.

Pepper Jack Cheese Spread - Large

Add:
Pepper Jack Cheese Spread - Large
Manufacturer: Wisconsin Made

Price: $5.49

Weight: 16oz

The classic taste of Pepper Jack in spreadable form.

Pico de Queso Cheddar

Add:
Pico de Queso Cheddar
Manufacturer: Henning's Cheese

Price: $5.99

Weight: 8oz

Creamy White Cheddar blended with Southwestern spices & Serrano peppers.